Taxstra Logo
Free tax planning tool

S-Corp Comparable-Pay Scaler

Scale credible comparable-market evidence for time and geography, then document the broader facts a real compensation conclusion requires.

No account required Educational, not individualized advice

Comparable-pay evidence

Use a credible salary survey, recruiter report, or comparable job set for the work actually performed.

Time-and-geography scaled range

$95,192 to $138,462

87% of the user-supplied full-time comparable

Scenario midpoint

$116,827

A comparable-pay discussion point, not a salary conclusion or safe harbor

Pre-wage profit entered

$240,000

Context only; profit does not set reasonable compensation

Input readiness

3/3

The scaler inputs are internally complete.

This is not a reasonable-compensation opinion. Training, duties, responsibilities, receipt sources, non-shareholder employees, capital, distributions, benefits, compensation agreements, and payment history require separate review.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call to talk through your next steps.

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

Educational estimate, updated August 23, 2026. The IRS does not prescribe one percentage. This scaler only adjusts user-supplied comparables for time and geography; it cannot weigh all facts and circumstances or issue a compensation opinion.

Worked example

Scaling a $110,000 to $160,000 comparable range for 1,800 owner hours

This is the calculator as it loads. An S-Corp owner has $240,000 of profit before owner wages and works about 1,800 hours a year in the business. A dated salary survey for the work the owner actually performs shows $110,000 to $160,000 for a full-time role in a comparable market.

Inputs

Worked example inputs
S-Corp profit before owner wages (context only)$240,000
Owner hours in the business1,800
Comparable full-time low$110,000
Comparable full-time high$160,000
Geographic adjustmentComparable market (100%)
Source and date of comparable evidence identifiedYes

Calculator output

Worked example calculator output
Time factor (hours / 2,080)87%
Time-and-geography scaled range$95,192 to $138,462
Scenario midpoint$116,827
Input readiness3/3

The range scales the comparable evidence for time and market. It is not a salary conclusion. Profit does not set the number: the IRS looks at what the owner does, how much time it takes, what comparable businesses pay for similar services, and whether the company’s receipts come from the owner’s own work or from employees, capital, and equipment.

Methodology

How this calculator works

The scaler adjusts comparable full-time pay you supply for the owner’s actual hours and for geography. It does not pick a salary.

Formulas

  • Time factor = owner hours / 2,080 (a 40-hour, 52-week year), held between 10% and 150%.
  • Scaled low = comparable full-time low x time factor x geographic factor. Scaled high uses the comparable high the same way.
  • Geographic factor = 85% (lower-cost market), 100% (comparable market), or 115% (higher-cost market).
  • Scenario midpoint = (scaled low + scaled high) / 2.
  • Input readiness counts three checks: documented source and date, hours entered, and a valid low-to-high range.

Assumptions

  • The comparable pay you enter is for the services the owner actually performs, from a credible, dated source.
  • Pay scales in a straight line with hours. Real roles often do not.
  • Profit is shown for context only. The IRS does not tie reasonable compensation to a percentage of profit.

What it ignores

  • The other IRS factors: training and experience, duties and responsibilities, dividend history, pay to non-shareholder employees, timing and manner of bonuses, compensation agreements, and use of a formula.
  • How much of the company’s gross receipts come from the owner’s services versus employees, capital, and equipment.
  • Payroll taxes, retirement plan and health insurance effects, the QBI deduction, and state rules.

Sources

Primary sources

  1. IRS: S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues: reasonable compensation factors and the source-of-gross-receipts analysis
  2. IRS Fact Sheet FS-2008-25: wage compensation for S corporation officers: officers are employees; distributions in lieu of wages can be recharacterized
  3. IRS Reasonable Compensation Job Aid for IRS Valuation Professionals: market, cost, and income approaches the IRS uses to test compensation
  4. 26 U.S. Code Section 3121: definitions for FICA, including officers as employees: Section 3121(d)(1)
  5. Treasury Regulation 31.3121(d)-1: who are employees: officers who perform more than minor services are employees

Educational, not individualized tax advice.

How to use the result

Use the answer as a decision screen

The result is designed to expose the variables worth investigating, not to replace transaction documents, tax returns, or professional judgment.

01

Stress-test your inputs

Run a base case and a conservative case. A decision that works only under perfect assumptions needs more diligence.

02

Separate cash from tax

A tax benefit cannot rescue weak economics. Evaluate operating cash, financing, and tax effects separately.

03

Document before acting

Save the source documents and assumptions a CPA will need to validate the treatment.

Take the next planning step

Request a planning follow-up

The useful answer stays on the page. Share your contact information only if you want Taxstra to follow up about the planning questions this tool surfaced.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call to talk through your next steps.

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

Prefer email? Ask us to follow up

Request a planning follow-up

Share your contact details and broad result category so Taxstra can follow up about the next questions worth answering. Your entries and calculated results are not attached.

Frequently asked questions

These answers explain the model’s boundaries.

Does the IRS provide a safe salary percentage?

No. Reasonable compensation is a facts-and-circumstances question. Duties, experience, time, comparable pay, and the source of company receipts all matter.

Is the displayed range a salary opinion?

No. It scales the comparable-pay evidence you enter. The output is only as defensible as that evidence and the documented role.

Why ask about the source of receipts?

The IRS distinguishes receipts generated by the shareholder’s services from receipts generated by employees, capital, or equipment.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call with our team

A free 30-minute call with our team about your needs, how we can help, and whether we are a good fit. Tax advice, document reviews, and analysis require a paid engagement.Your tax plan and specific advice come after you engage. The call is about fit and next steps.

Or call (217) 788-0750

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

★ 5.0 on Google113 reviews4.9 from 114 BiggerPockets reviews1,000+ clientsAll 50 states, fully remote

Need help evaluating or running an S corporation?

A comparison or calculator is a starting point. Discuss the owner’s work, payroll, operating states, books, and filing responsibilities together.

Explore S-corp CPA services →