Taxstra Logo
Free tax planning tool

Rental Property Deal Lab

Get the cap-rate answer first, then see financing, cash-on-cash return, depreciation, and a conservative gross tax-shield scenario.

No account required Educational, not individualized advice

Property economics

Financing and tax scenario

Cap rate

7.4%

$33,380 NOI ÷ $450,000 price

Cash-on-cash return

5.2%

$7,112 annual cash flow

Annual debt service

$26,268

$337,500 modeled loan

Gross first-year depreciation scenario

$88,200

$14,000 full-year straight-line baseline

Incremental gross tax-shield scenario

$23,744

$74,200 incremental depreciation × entered marginal rate, only if fully usable

The modeled gross tax shield is $28,224, but this is not cash savings or an after-tax return. Timing and loss-limit rules can defer or eliminate current-year use.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call to talk through your next steps.

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

Educational estimate, updated August 23, 2026. Residential building basis is modeled over 27.5 years. The accelerated-basis scenario is intentionally illustrative and excludes placed-in-service timing, bonus-depreciation eligibility, passive-loss, at-risk, interest-allocation, recapture, and state rules. A real cost-segregation result requires property-level support.

Worked example

A $450,000 rental with a 20% accelerated-basis scenario

This is the calculator as it loads. A $450,000 rental rents for $4,200 a month with a 5% vacancy allowance and $14,500 of annual operating expenses. The buyer puts $112,500 down, finances the rest at 6.75% over 30 years, and spends $25,000 on immediate improvements.

Inputs

Worked example inputs
Purchase price$450,000
Monthly rent$4,200
Vacancy allowance5%
Annual operating expenses$14,500
Down payment$112,500
Interest rate and term6.75%, 30 years
Immediate improvements$25,000
Land allocation20%
Modeled accelerated basis20%
Marginal tax rate32%

Calculator output

Worked example calculator output
Net operating income$33,380
Cap rate7.4%
Annual debt service$26,268
Annual cash flow$7,112
Cash-on-cash return5.2%
Full-year straight-line depreciation$14,000
First-year depreciation scenario$88,200
Incremental gross tax-shield scenario$23,744

The depreciable building basis is $385,000: the price less 20% land, plus the improvements. The scenario deducts 20% of that basis in year one and spreads the rest over 27.5 years. The tax shield is gross: it is not cash savings, and passive-loss rules can defer the deduction.

Methodology

How this calculator works

The calculator separates first-year operating economics from a depreciation scenario so a tax benefit cannot hide a weak deal.

Formulas

  • Net operating income = (monthly rent x 12 + other income) x (1 minus vacancy) minus operating expenses.
  • Cap rate = NOI / purchase price. Cash-on-cash return = (NOI minus annual debt service) / (down payment + immediate improvements).
  • Annual debt service = the level monthly payment on (price minus down payment) at the entered rate and term, x 12.
  • Building basis = price x (1 minus land %) + improvements. Straight-line baseline = basis / 27.5.
  • Depreciation scenario = basis x accelerated % in year one + the remaining basis / 27.5.
  • Incremental tax shield = (scenario minus straight-line depreciation) x your entered marginal rate.

Assumptions

  • A full year of depreciation, with no mid-month convention for the month placed in service.
  • The accelerated share is treated as fully deducted in year one, as 100% bonus depreciation allows for qualifying property acquired after January 19, 2025. The percentage is your scenario input, not a cost segregation study.
  • The whole deduction is usable at the marginal rate you enter.

What it ignores

  • Passive activity loss limits, the $25,000 rental allowance, at-risk and excess business loss rules.
  • Depreciation recapture on sale, closing costs, principal paydown, appreciation, and capital reserves.
  • State depreciation conformity and state income tax.

Sources

Primary sources

  1. 26 U.S. Code Section 168: accelerated cost recovery system: 27.5-year residential recovery period, mid-month convention, and bonus depreciation in 168(k)
  2. IRS Publication 527: residential rental property: rental income, expenses, and depreciation of rental property
  3. IRS Publication 946: how to depreciate property: basis, land allocation, MACRS tables, and special depreciation allowance
  4. Instructions for Form 4562: where bonus and MACRS depreciation are reported
  5. IRS Publication 5653: Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide: what a supported cost segregation study must show
  6. 26 U.S. Code Section 469: passive activity losses: why a rental loss may not be usable in the current year

Educational, not individualized tax advice.

How to use the result

Use the answer as a decision screen

The result is designed to expose the variables worth investigating, not to replace transaction documents, tax returns, or professional judgment.

01

Stress-test your inputs

Run a base case and a conservative case. A decision that works only under perfect assumptions needs more diligence.

02

Separate cash from tax

A tax benefit cannot rescue weak economics. Evaluate operating cash, financing, and tax effects separately.

03

Document before acting

Save the source documents and assumptions a CPA will need to validate the treatment.

Take the next planning step

Request a planning follow-up

The useful answer stays on the page. Share your contact information only if you want Taxstra to follow up about the planning questions this tool surfaced.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call to talk through your next steps.

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

Prefer email? Ask us to follow up

Request a planning follow-up

Share your contact details and broad result category so Taxstra can follow up about the next questions worth answering. Your entries and calculated results are not attached.

Frequently asked questions

These answers explain the model’s boundaries.

What expenses belong in cap rate?

Use recurring property-level operating expenses before mortgage principal and interest. Keep financing out of NOI so properties can be compared consistently.

Is the cost-segregation estimate a study?

No. The accelerated-basis percentage is a scenario input, not an engineering study or a depreciation schedule.

Does a higher cap rate make a good deal?

Not by itself. Vacancy, capital expenditures, tenant quality, financing, local risk, and the durability of rent all matter.

Book your free 30-minute tax fit call with our team

A free 30-minute call with our team about your needs, how we can help, and whether we are a good fit. Tax advice, document reviews, and analysis require a paid engagement.Your tax plan and specific advice come after you engage. The call is about fit and next steps.

Or call (217) 788-0750

Tax planning slots are limited before year-end.

★ 5.0 on Google113 reviews4.9 from 114 BiggerPockets reviews1,000+ clientsAll 50 states, fully remote