Taxstra Logo

Best States for 1099 Physicians

Compare the state taxes, living costs and malpractice insurance costs that matter when you work as an independent physician.

The published 50-state ranking

Compare the state taxes, living costs and malpractice insurance costs that matter when you work as an independent physician.

Higher scores mean a stronger result on the factors this guide measures. They do not guarantee a better fit for your household or investment. Ties stay tied, and missing data is clearly marked.

Taxstra’s published 2026 ranking. One methodology, applied consistently to every state. 80% financial evidence and 20% WalletHub Quality of Life. See the factors and scoring rules.

Pick a state. See how it fits.

Explore grades out of 10, category ranks and the tradeoffs behind them. Each state uses the same published factors and weights.

The map loads when the page opens. All 50 states are available in the selector and table.

1 / 1010 / 10

Gray = unavailable or provisional; no comparable rank. Alaska and Hawaii shown as insets.

Boundaries: U.S. Census Bureau / US Atlas.

Why Illinois scores this way

Illinois ranks #41 of 50, with 5.0 / 10. 2 states share this rank.

A higher category score means a stronger result on that measure. Check the “Good fit for” and “Less suited to” notes against your own priorities.

Taxstra Tax and Accounting Services2026 state guide

1099 physicians

Illinois

Taxstra’s state comparison

Illinois outline
5.0/ 10

Overall score#41 in the comparison

80% cost and financial score (3.9/10) · 20% quality of life (9.3/10)

How to read this score

Uses a separately supplied $500K state-taxable ordinary-business base, regional spending and CMS relative malpractice costs. Does not derive a return from $500K profit or assume a contractor pay premium. Entity charges, retirement contributions, federal payroll and assignment-state sourcing remain separate.

State tax on $500K of taxable business income

#28 of 50 · 24% weight
5.2/10

$24,750 in state income tax in our $500,000 taxable-business-income example; business fees, payroll and local taxes are separate.

Everyday living costs

#33 of 50 · 32% weight
5.1/10

$99,958. What a $100,000 national spending budget would cost here; lower costs score better.

Malpractice insurance costs

#50 of 50 · 24% weight
1.0/10

2.20 on the CMS cost index; a lower number means lower relative insurance costs, not a quote for your specialty.

Quality of life

#5 of 50 · WalletHub category · 20% weight
9.3/10

WalletHub: #5 for Quality of Life, #18 overall; this score uses the category.

Home prices compared with pay

#21 of 50 · Not in overall score
8.4/10

1.22 ×. Home price divided by annual family-physician pay; lower means housing is more affordable relative to pay.

Homeowner property taxes

#45 of 50 · Not in overall score
5.2/10

$5,399 typical annual homeowner tax bill; check the specific property before budgeting.

Good fit for

  • Physicians with a strong specific offer who value Illinois amenities and manageable purchase prices
  • Contractors whose paid hours and coverage terms are documented

Less suited to

  • Buyers treating an inexpensive listing as proof of low long-term carrying costs
  • Budgets treating gross collections or an hourly quote as spendable annual income

Illinois: full analysis and evidenceRead the state-specific explanation and supporting sources.

Illinois

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $280,700Monthly gross rent $1,322HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,480

Illinois’s general price index is almost exactly national average, while its homeowner tax observation is well above Indiana’s and Iowa’s. Contractors holding profit constant should compare total home-base costs before assuming the modest purchase value is the whole story. Malpractice renewal terms also merit explicit attention because the cited study identifies selected premium increases, not a complete annual coverage price.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $99,958 (cost position 33). ACS median homeowner tax is $5,399 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,480 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 9.7%; sample 93.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 2.201 for Illinois, using published malpractice RVUs across 101 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Illinois retirement-tax details

Cite the state. Include the method.

Use the state, guide title, published methodology and source years when citing a score. State selection changes the card, not the ranking methodology.

Media and interview inquiries · Source data · Taxstra methodology

Full ranking table · 50 of 50 statesCompare every state’s rank, housing costs, property taxes and tax treatment.

50 of 50 states

1099 physicians: economic observations and tax context
RankStatePhysician contractor tax, cost and lifestyle gradeHome value
ACS 2024
Property-tax bill
ACS 2024 median
Price index
BEA 2024
Individual bonus treatment
1Iowa8.4 / 10$227,300$2,93787.8Iowa follows current federal depreciation, including §168(k) and §168(n), for 2026 to 2027.
2South Dakota8.4 / 10$289,600$2,94088.6South Dakota does not impose a broad individual income tax.
3North Dakota7.9 / 10$266,100$2,55089.0North Dakota follows the federal deductions through its current federal income starting point.
4Tennessee7.9 / 10$332,600$1,48891.9Tennessee does not impose a broad individual income tax.
5Texas7.8 / 10$313,200$4,10897.1Texas does not impose a broad individual income tax.
6Ohio7.6 / 10$239,800$2,93792.8For §168(k), generally add back five-sixths and deduct one-fifth of that addback in each of the next five years. Payroll-growth and NOL exceptions can change the result; §168(n) generally follows federal law.
7Indiana7.5 / 10$243,500$1,79893.3Add back federal bonus depreciation and maintain Indiana basis for later depreciation or disposition.
8Kansas7.5 / 10$238,700$2,98390.1Current Kansas statutes recognize federal §168(k); a direct current official statement on §168(n) was not located.
9Wyoming7.5 / 10$339,500$1,94792.7Wyoming does not impose a broad individual income tax.
10Nebraska7.4 / 10$263,100$3,73990.1Nebraska follows the current federal depreciation deduction for 2026 to 2027.
11Wisconsin7.4 / 10$294,700$3,68094.1Wisconsin does not adopt federal §168(k) or §168(n); compute Wisconsin depreciation separately.
12North Carolina7.2 / 10$333,000$2,04494.3Add back 85% of the federal accelerated-depreciation amount, then deduct 20% of that addition in each of the next five years.
13Arkansas7.2 / 10$215,600$1,11386.9Federal bonus depreciation is not adopted; use the Arkansas depreciation computation.
13Oklahoma7.2 / 10$222,100$1,67287.8Oklahoma permits a state 100% expensing election for qualifying property; it is not simple federal bonus conformity.
15Nevada7.1 / 10$455,500$2,143100.0Nevada does not impose a broad individual income tax.
16Louisiana7.0 / 10$223,200$1,18788.2Louisiana offers an optional state 100% expensing deduction for qualifying property; later federal depreciation on the same basis is added back.
17Pennsylvania7.0 / 10$277,600$3,21497.6Pennsylvania personal income tax uses its own depreciation rules rather than the federal bonus amount.
18Mississippi6.8 / 10$186,500$1,22187.0Mississippi permits a state 100% first-year deduction for qualifying depreciable property; it is not simple federal bonus conformity.
19Alabama6.8 / 10$233,300$89088.8Follows the federal §168(k) and §168(n) deductions for 2026 to 2027.
20Washington6.7 / 10$602,200$4,729107.0Washington does not impose a broad individual income tax.
21Missouri6.7 / 10$254,400$2,02190.8Missouri follows current federal depreciation and does not require a bonus addback for current property.
22Kentucky6.5 / 10$226,000$1,61190.2Kentucky does not adopt the current federal bonus provisions; use Kentucky depreciation.
23Idaho6.4 / 10$446,400$1,91295.5Add back the federal bonus difference in the first year; deduct later Idaho-versus-federal depreciation differences.
24Arizona6.4 / 10$426,000$1,828100.7Individuals retain the full federal §168(k) bonus amount for eligible new property in 2026; §168(n) is separately added back.
25Florida6.3 / 10$396,900$2,993103.4Florida does not impose a broad individual income tax.
26Minnesota6.3 / 10$344,600$3,50198.6For §168(k), add back 80% and deduct one-fifth of that addition in each of the next five years. Qualified production property under §168(n) is not added back.
27Colorado6.2 / 10$574,600$2,828103.1Colorado follows the federal deductions for §168(k) bonus and §168(n) qualified production property.
28Michigan6.2 / 10$254,200$2,98896.2For individuals and flow-through entities, Michigan retains the pre-OBBBA phaseout: 20% federal bonus in 2026 and 0% in 2027; §168(n) is disallowed.
29South Carolina6.1 / 10$299,500$1,33793.7Use South Carolina depreciation without federal §168(k) or §168(n).
30New Mexico6.1 / 10$279,900$1,77692.2Ordinary §168(k) bonus flows into individual income in 2026. The enacted 2027 depreciation reversal changes the corporate base, not the individual base.
31Alaska6.1 / 10$376,500$3,976102.4Alaska does not impose a broad individual income tax.
32New Hampshire6.0 / 10$458,800$6,707104.2New Hampshire does not impose a broad individual income tax.
33Maine5.9 / 10$341,900$3,10397.1Add back the federal bonus amount and claim depreciation under Maine’s pro-forma computation.
34Georgia5.9 / 10$343,300$2,55496.3Use Georgia depreciation without federal §168(k) or §168(n).
34Montana5.9 / 10$425,400$2,93994.6Montana begins with the current federal income base and has no current bonus-depreciation addback.
36Utah5.8 / 10$545,200$2,64898.9Utah starts with current federal adjusted gross income and does not enumerate a §168(k) or §168(n) reversal.
37Massachusetts5.7 / 10$607,400$6,080105.8§168(k) remains disallowed. §168(n) is disallowed for 2026 and follows federal law beginning in 2027.
38Virginia5.7 / 10$403,500$2,872101.1Recompute Virginia depreciation as though the federal bonus provisions did not apply.
39West Virginia5.6 / 10$170,800$88189.5West Virginia adopted the 2025 federal changes, so §168(k) and §168(n) flow through for 2026 to 2027.
40Vermont5.2 / 10$352,800$5,02698.0Vermont disallows §168(k) and §168(n), then permits recovery under the non-bonus depreciation schedule.
41California5.0 / 10$759,500$5,369110.7California does not conform to federal bonus depreciation; compute California depreciation separately.
41Illinois5.0 / 10$280,700$5,399100.0Reverse federal §168(k)/§168(n) amounts and compute the Illinois depreciation modification.
43Oregon4.9 / 10$497,500$3,895103.4Oregon disallows federal bonus depreciation for 2026 to 2027; implementing recovery instructions are pending.
44New Jersey4.8 / 10$496,000$9,358108.8New Jersey does not follow the federal bonus deduction; calculate New Jersey depreciation and basis separately.
45Connecticut4.6 / 10$396,900$6,573103.6Add back 100% of federal bonus, then deduct 25% of the addition in each of the next four years.
46Delaware4.6 / 10$371,600$1,75099.8Ordinary eligible 2026 property retains 20% bonus under the pre-OBBBA schedule; the rest follows regular depreciation.
47Rhode Island4.6 / 10$455,700$4,886102.3Compute depreciation and basis as though federal bonus depreciation had not been enacted.
48Maryland4.5 / 10$436,300$4,144105.0Generally decoupled from federal bonus; qualifying manufacturing property may receive different treatment.
49New York4.5 / 10$449,800$6,542107.9Reverse federal §168(k) and §168(n) deductions and claim New York depreciation.
50Hawaii3.6 / 10$875,900$2,385110.0Hawaii does not allow the federal bonus deduction; compute Hawaii depreciation separately.
Business tax scenariosFixed examples of entity taxes, owner compensation and payroll costs.

Compare owner, entity and payroll tax separately

An S election changes how the business pays its owner. Start with the same $500,000 of operating profit, then compare federal employment taxes, the regular owner-income benchmark and the state entity components that can actually be calculated.

2026 rules · verified September 12, 2026 · educational, not individualized tax advice. These are controlled illustrations, not tax returns. Each state base is a separate input; the tool never assumes gross profit is the state-taxable base.

Published comparison assumptions

$500,000 operating profit before owner pay; $250,000 owner wages; $1.5 million current and prior-year in-state receipts; a separately supplied $500,000 owner state-taxable ordinary-business base and $234,936 state entity-income base. The owner files jointly, has no other wages and conducts all activity in the selected state. The fixed $500,000 non-owner payroll is already deducted in operating profit.

Illinois: the layers behind the decision

Regular owner tax on supplied business base
$24,750
Sole proprietor federal employment taxes
$38,175
S-corp employer + employee FICA/Additional Medicare
$30,128
Remaining S-corp profit after owner pay/employer FICA
$234,936

The federal employment-tax difference is $8,047, before income-tax effects and compliance costs; it is not a net savings recommendation. It is the same nationwide under these facts. The separate state entity base does not automatically change with salary because state additions and deductions may differ.

Illinois DOR current income-tax rates · IRS Publication 15, 2026 employer payroll taxes · IRS: self-employment tax, net earnings and deduction · IRS: Additional Medicare Tax thresholds and mixed wages/self-employment · IRS S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues

Separately calculated Illinois entity components

Entity examples use $500,000 non-owner payroll, wages paid evenly each quarter, $250,000 net worth/assets where needed, all in-state activity and no special exemption. New Hampshire models the current-year BET credit against BPT instead of adding both gross taxes. Washington uses ordinary service B&O and the stated prior-year receipts. Local taxes, SUTA/FUTA and other fees remain separate.

Exact scenario assumptions and limits
  • One full-year resident owner, married filing jointly, no other wages, all business activity in the selected state.
  • $500,000 operating profit is after non-owner expenses. The separate five-person $500,000 payroll has already been deducted, and is never deducted twice.
  • $1.5 million revenue and $250,000 owner wages are illustrative controlled inputs, not empirical averages or a reasonable-compensation conclusion.
  • Owner-income comparison supplies $500,000 of state-taxable ordinary business income. It is a separate rate/base benchmark, not a derivation of state taxable income from gross profit.
  • Entity illustration separately supplies $234,936 of state entity income after owner wages and employer FICA; state-specific modifications have to be reconciled before an actual return.
  • No PTET election, local tax, credits, AMT, capital gains, state special-rate election or personalized deductions in the regular owner benchmark. Ohio business-income rules are separately applied.
50 states: regular owner benchmark and separately sourced entity components; no all-in total
StateRegular owner benchmarkEntity componentsSource / scope
Alabama$24,920Not fully calculatedAlabama DOR individual tax rates
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Alaska$0Not fully calculatedAlaska government tax facts
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Arizona$12,500Not fully calculatedArizona DOR individual withholding and tax rate
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Arkansas$18,420Not fully calculatedArkansas DFA 2026 special-session SB1 fiscal impact · Arkansas SB1, Act 2 of the 2026 special session
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
California$39,135

Regular nonfinancial S corporation franchise tax: $3,524
California FTB S corporation tax and minimum tax

California FTB September 3, 2026 indexing memorandum, Attachment 2 (CalTax-hosted copy) · California FTB 2025 Publication 1067: individual-return 1% tax on excess over $1 million
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Colorado$22,000Not fully calculatedColorado 2026 DR 0104EP estimate worksheet
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Connecticut$30,800Not fully calculatedConnecticut 2026 CT-1040ES: initial tax, 2% phaseout and recapture tables
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Delaware$31,984Not fully calculatedDelaware DOR employer guide, income computation table
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Florida$0Not fully calculatedFlorida DOR individual income-tax FAQ
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Georgia$24,950Not fully calculatedGeorgia DOR important tax updates, 2026
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Hawaii$37,432Not fully calculatedHawaii Department of Taxation tax-year rate tables · Hawaii tax tables for years after December 31, 2024
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Idaho$25,977Not fully calculatedIdaho Code 63-3024: 5.3% rate and statutory CPI indexing · BLS CPI-U U.S. city average: 2025 annual average 321.943 · BLS historical CPI-U: 1998 annual average 163.0 · Idaho Commission published annual tables: latest posted year 2025 · BLS archived CPI files: October 2025 data unavailable during funding lapse
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Illinois$24,750

S corporation replacement tax: $3,524
Illinois DOR current income-tax rates

Illinois DOR current income-tax rates
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Indiana$14,750Not fully calculatedIndiana DOR rates, fees and penalties
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Iowa$19,000Not fully calculatedIowa DOR 2026 income-tax rate announcement
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Kansas$27,725Not fully calculatedKansas DOR enacted individual tax schedule · Kansas Notice 25-06: no 2026 rate reduction
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Kentucky$17,500

LLET small-business minimum: $175
Kentucky DOR limited liability entity tax

Kentucky DOR software developer tax-year updates
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Louisiana$15,000Not fully calculatedLouisiana DOR individual income-tax reform rates
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Maine$34,710Not fully calculatedMaine Revenue Services revised 2026 individual rate schedules
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Maryland$26,573Not fully calculatedMaryland Tax-General section 10-105
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Massachusetts$25,000Not fully calculatedMassachusetts DOR current tax rates
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Michigan$21,250Not fully calculatedMichigan Treasury 2026 individual rate determination
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Minnesota$39,754Not fully calculatedMinnesota DOR 2026 rates and brackets
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Mississippi$19,600

S corporation franchise tax: $75
Mississippi DOR current business income and 2026 franchise rates

Mississippi DOR general information, 2026 income tax
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Missouri$23,320Not fully calculatedMissouri DOR 2026 MO-1040ES tax rate chart
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Montana$27,348Not fully calculatedMontana DOR HB 337 income-tax changes
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Nebraska$22,148Not fully calculatedNebraska DOR 2026 Form 1040N-ES worksheet
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Nevada$0

General-business modified business tax: $6,435
Nevada DOR modified business tax

Commerce Tax: $0
Nevada DOR commerce tax FAQ

Nevada Department of Taxation tax notes
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
New Hampshire$0

Business enterprise tax: $4,125
New Hampshire DRA: BPT, BET and credit interaction

Business profits tax after current-year BET credit: $13,495
New Hampshire DRA: BPT, BET and credit interaction

New Hampshire DRA interest and dividends tax repeal
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
New Jersey$27,808Not fully calculatedNew Jersey Treasury resident tax rate schedules, 2020 and after
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
New Mexico$25,539Not fully calculatedNew Mexico TRD 2025 tax expenditure report: 2025-and-later income schedule · New Mexico TRD January 2026 SB60 analysis: current-law comparison table
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
New York$34,250Not fully calculatedNew York 2026 IT-2105-I estimate schedules and benefit-recapture worksheets
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
North Carolina$19,950Not fully calculatedNorth Carolina DOR individual rate schedules
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
North Dakota$9,209Not fully calculatedNorth Dakota 2026 ND-1ES annual tax rate schedules
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Ohio$7,500Not fully calculatedOhio Revised Code chapter 5747: business deduction and distinct 3% rate
Business base before Ohio deduction.
Oklahoma$22,071Not fully calculatedOklahoma Tax Commission 2025 legislative update, effective 2026
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Oregon$45,987

S corporation minimum excise tax: $150
Oregon DOR corporate filing requirements and S corporation minimum tax

Oregon Legislative Revenue Office 2026 personal tax schedule
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Pennsylvania$15,350Not fully calculatedPennsylvania DOR 2026 REV-413 individual estimated tax
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Rhode Island$26,818Not fully calculatedRhode Island Division of Taxation 2026 inflation adjustments · Rhode Island DOR July 2026 enacted-law summary: surtax starts in 2027
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
South Carolina$25,084Not fully calculatedSouth Carolina DOR H.4216 2026 income-tax reform
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
South Dakota$0Not fully calculatedSouth Dakota DOR sales and use tax guide
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Tennessee$0

Excise tax after standard deduction: $12,021
Tennessee DOR franchise and excise rates · Tennessee franchise and excise tax manual, standard deduction

Franchise tax on supplied net-worth base: $625
Tennessee DOR franchise and excise rates · Tennessee DOR FT-1: franchise tax net-worth base and minimum

Tennessee DOR Hall income tax repeal
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Texas$0

2026/2027 report franchise tax below threshold: $0
Texas Comptroller 2026 franchise report threshold and information filing

Texas Constitution article VIII section 24-a
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Utah$22,250Not fully calculatedUtah Tax Commission 2026 legislative summary
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Vermont$35,361

Business entity minimum tax: $250
Vermont Department of Taxes business entity income tax

Vermont Joint Fiscal Office 2026 Fiscal Facts: personal income-tax brackets · Vermont 32 VSA 5822: federal-AGI minimum tax
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Virginia$28,493Not fully calculatedVirginia Tax individual income-tax computation
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Washington$0

Service and Other Activities B&O: $26,250
Washington DOR: 2026 service B&O tiers

Washington DOR individual income-tax FAQs · Washington Governor: SB6346 income tax signed March 30, 2026; starts January 2028
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
West Virginia$22,103Not fully calculatedWest Virginia Tax Division 2026 personal income-tax reduction
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Wisconsin$27,020Not fully calculatedWisconsin DOR 2026 Form 1-ES instructions
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
Wyoming$0

Annual license tax: $60
Wyoming Secretary of State annual license tax

State of Wyoming tax overview
Supplied ordinary-income base; standard schedule.
What changes the comparisonThe tax, legal and financial tradeoffs behind the ranking.

Compare a physician contractor’s home base using owner business-income tax, household costs, relative malpractice insurance costs and a fixed quality-of-life category weight. The guide separates those ranked observations from a $500,000 practice-profit illustration, federal employment taxes and actual entity charges. Your assignments, professional structure and contract determine the final result.

What determines this guide’s grade

30% controlled owner business-income tax, 40% regional spending basket, 30% CMS malpractice cost index within the financial share. The published ranking gives financial evidence 80% and the named quality-of-life category 20%, consistently across all states. These are Taxstra’s editorial weights, not estimated predictors of future results. Uses a separately supplied $500K state-taxable ordinary-business base, regional spending and CMS relative malpractice costs. Does not derive a return from $500K profit or assume a contractor pay premium. Entity charges, retirement contributions, federal payroll and assignment-state sourcing remain separate.

Do not annualize the hourly rate over every week

Build the year from committed paid shifts, expected cancellations, credentialing delays, travel days and time off. A contract with a lower hourly rate can leave more annual profit if it offers more reliable paid hours or covers travel and insurance. A published BLS employee wage cannot fill a missing 1099 rate. The statewide notes therefore show employee pay only as negotiation context.

Resident state and assignment state are two separate decisions

A home in a low-cost state may help the household budget while assignments elsewhere still require nonresident filings. Track where services are performed and reconcile resident credits, withholding and estimates. Organizing an entity elsewhere does not relocate the physician’s actual services. The score awards no point for paper incorporation or for an unverified absence of tax.

Professional structure comes before the S election

Federal tax classification and authority to practice medicine are separate questions. California’s Medical Board, for example, lists practicing through an LLC among prohibited structures in its guidance. Have qualified counsel confirm the lawful professional entity, ownership and clinical-control arrangement before the CPA models an election. A generic online LLC recommendation can miss this first step.

Reasonable compensation is based on the services

IRS guidance requires reasonable compensation for an S-corp shareholder’s services before nonwage distributions. A solo clinical practice relies heavily on that owner’s work. The library’s fixed $250,000 owner wage is an illustrative assumption requiring a facts-based review; it is not a recommended physician salary. Model employer payroll cost, state entity charges, administration and retirement contributions together.

Insurance quotes must follow the specialty and assignment

Ask for policy form, retroactive date, limits, covered services, locations and tail arrangements. In fund states, distinguish the underlying policy from the fund surcharge or assessment. The AMA change series can help identify a renewal question but cannot price your policy, and its insurer/specialty observations are not percentages of doctors experiencing an increase.

Retirement accounts require cash, not just a deduction

A one-participant 401(k) is intended for a business owner without common-law employees, or the owner and spouse; eligible employees change the analysis. IRS guidance says elective deferral limits follow the person across plans. A physician with both hospital employment and contracting should coordinate contributions rather than counting the employee limit twice.

Choose a sustainable operating calendar

Price accounting, licenses, credentialing, coverage renewals and entity filings before comparing state tax savings. Washington physician services, for example, fall within the service-and-other-activities B&O classification; an individual income-tax slogan does not describe that business obligation. Keep a reserve for estimated payments and an assignment ending sooner than expected.

Put the numbers in contextA worked example with explicit assumptions.

Controlled contract example: $300 per hour × 1,800 paid hours produces $540,000 of receipts; $280 × 2,000 paid hours produces $560,000. If expenses are identical, the lower hourly rate produces $20,000 more gross receipts over the year. Neither example is a market-rate claim or a forecast of available shifts.

Illustration only. These assumptions describe the example, not an expected client result.

Every state, explainedBrowse all 50 state chapters, with detailed analysis and linked evidence.
AlabamaRead state analysis

Alabama

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $233,300Monthly gross rent $1,077HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,906

Alabama makes a useful home-base comparison with neighboring Georgia: the imported spending basket, median rent and homeowner property-tax bill are all lower. A contractor with similar reliable net profit in both places should price the actual housing and travel arrangement next. A Birmingham-area assignment and a distant home base can add expenses that a statewide cost index cannot identify.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $88,823 (cost position 7). ACS median homeowner tax is $890 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,906 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.564 for Alabama, using published malpractice RVUs across 67 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Alabama retirement-tax details
AlaskaRead state analysis

Alaska

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $376,500Monthly gross rent $1,444HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,216

Alaska is an example of why a contractor’s home base and an assignment should be priced separately. The local price basket is more expensive than Wyoming’s or Montana’s, while a short engagement may involve distinct transport and temporary-housing costs. Ask who pays those costs and how cancelled travel affects paid shifts before extrapolating a rate over a full year.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $102,359 (cost position 38). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,976 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,216 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.517 for Alaska, using published malpractice RVUs across 29 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Alaska retirement-tax details
ArizonaRead state analysis

Arizona

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $426,000Monthly gross rent $1,672HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,194

Arizona’s household screen benefits from relatively modest historical homeowners insurance, but its statewide rent is much higher than New Mexico’s. A physician moving for several contracts should compare renting near the work with purchasing a permanent base. The apparent stability of owner carrying costs does not establish what a furnished short-term rental or repeated travel will cost.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $100,677 (cost position 35). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,828 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,194 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.870 for Arizona, using published malpractice RVUs across 15 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: Current primary guidance verified the election and rate, but not a single unqualified statement that every excess owner credit is refundable.

Read the Arizona retirement-tax details
ArkansasRead state analysis

Arkansas

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $215,600Monthly gross rent $982HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,870

Arkansas’s low spending basket is directly relevant when net contract profit is held constant, which is why its contractor screen can look much better than its employee-pay screen. Median rent and homeowner taxes are also modest. The main next step is to establish that actual paid work, travel and insurance allow the assumed profit to remain comparable across destinations.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $86,937 (cost position 1). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,113 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,870 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.519 for Arkansas, using published malpractice RVUs across 74 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: Owner credit utilization still requires the owner return; payment arithmetic is implemented separately.

Read the Arkansas retirement-tax details
CaliforniaRead state analysis

California

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $759,500Monthly gross rent $2,104HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,655

California’s contractor problem begins before tax optimization: establish a permitted medical-practice structure, then price the assignment against an expensive home base. Its statewide median rent is the highest here, and the owner housing benchmark is also large. A contract premium needs to cover those household costs, paid versus unpaid time and practice expenses; an S election is not a substitute for that comparison.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $110,720 (cost position 50). ACS median homeowner tax is $5,369 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,655 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

California’s Medical Board lists an LLC among prohibited medical-practice structures. Civil Code 3333.2 produces 2026 noneconomic limits of $470,000 for non-death injury and $650,000 for wrongful death in each applicable category; separate categories can apply. Neither figure limits all damages or prices insurance. Have counsel review the structure and coverage.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.550 for California, using published malpractice RVUs across 57 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the California retirement-tax details
ColoradoRead state analysis

Colorado

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $574,600Monthly gross rent $1,822HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,492

Colorado’s household screen faces pressure from both the spending basket and historical homeowners insurance. The insurance observation is more than twice Utah’s, although the coverage and risks differ. A contractor should obtain an address-specific quote before choosing a permanent base and compare housing near the work rather than assuming a statewide average prices a Front Range or mountain assignment.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $103,052 (cost position 39). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,828 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,492 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.744 for Colorado, using published malpractice RVUs across 63 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Colorado retirement-tax details
ConnecticutRead state analysis

Connecticut

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $396,900Monthly gross rent $1,550HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,036

Connecticut’s owner household costs deserve separate attention even when contract profit is strong. The homeowner property-tax observation is several times Delaware’s, and the historical insurance amount is higher too. A physician who rents or maintains a home elsewhere should not treat these owner statistics as assignment expenses; substitute the actual arrangement and track paid travel days.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $103,610 (cost position 42). ACS median homeowner tax is $6,573 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,036 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.229 for Connecticut, using published malpractice RVUs across 9 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Connecticut retirement-tax details
DelawareRead state analysis

Delaware

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $371,600Monthly gross rent $1,530HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,196

Delaware compares favorably with nearby New Jersey on the imported homeowner tax and insurance amounts. Those observations can help a contractor screen a home base, but they do not settle the tax consequences of assignments across state lines. Write down the residence, each work location and travel expense before treating a regional practice as a single-state business.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $99,808 (cost position 32). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,750 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,196 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.861 for Delaware, using published malpractice RVUs across 3 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Delaware retirement-tax details
FloridaRead state analysis

Florida

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $396,900Monthly gross rent $1,812HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,779

Florida’s historical homeowners premium is among the largest observations and its rent benchmark is expensive. A contractor choosing a home base needs property-specific insurance and travel quotes before comparing margin with Georgia or Tennessee. The new malpractice-change evidence adds a renewal question, but it cannot substitute for the physician’s specialty, coverage limits and actual insurer quote.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $103,414 (cost position 41). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,993 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,779 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 19%; sample 63.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.716 for Florida, using published malpractice RVUs across 67 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Florida retirement-tax details
GeorgiaRead state analysis

Georgia

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $343,300Monthly gross rent $1,506HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,828

Georgia’s general prices are below the national benchmark, but its median rent is materially higher than Alabama’s and Tennessee’s. A contracting physician should compare the actual home base, airport access and assignment travel costs before choosing a neighborhood. The score does not assume all Georgia locations or locum arrangements inherit the same statewide cost advantage.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $96,293 (cost position 25). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,554 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,828 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 12.5%; sample 24.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.281 for Georgia, using published malpractice RVUs across 154 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9999%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Georgia retirement-tax details
HawaiiRead state analysis

Hawaii

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $875,900Monthly gross rent $1,942HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,549

Hawaii is difficult to reduce to a contractor tax comparison because the household basket and housing are expensive before travel is considered. Decide whether the opportunity is a temporary assignment or a permanent move, then price each accordingly. Paid travel, accommodation and cancellation provisions may be more useful negotiation items than a nominally higher hourly rate.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $109,951 (cost position 49). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,385 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,549 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.605 for Hawaii, using published malpractice RVUs across 4 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9997%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Hawaii retirement-tax details
IdahoRead state analysis

Idaho

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $446,400Monthly gross rent $1,384HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,135

Idaho has a low historical homeowners insurance observation, but a contractor arriving as a buyer faces a substantial home-price benchmark. Renting near an assignment can answer a different financial question from buying a permanent base. Compare the net contract margin after actual housing, travel and paid-time assumptions with alternatives in Wyoming and neighboring states.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $95,494 (cost position 23). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,912 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,135 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.491 for Idaho, using published malpractice RVUs across 42 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Idaho retirement-tax details
IllinoisRead state analysis

Illinois

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $280,700Monthly gross rent $1,322HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,480

Illinois’s general price index is almost exactly national average, while its homeowner tax observation is well above Indiana’s and Iowa’s. Contractors holding profit constant should compare total home-base costs before assuming the modest purchase value is the whole story. Malpractice renewal terms also merit explicit attention because the cited study identifies selected premium increases, not a complete annual coverage price.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $99,958 (cost position 33). ACS median homeowner tax is $5,399 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,480 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 9.7%; sample 93.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 2.201 for Illinois, using published malpractice RVUs across 101 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Illinois retirement-tax details
IndianaRead state analysis

Indiana

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $243,500Monthly gross rent $1,104HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,259

Indiana’s contractor household screen benefits from moderate property taxes and historical insurance, with prices well below national average. Its malpractice fund adds a distinct operational item: confirm provider qualification and who pays any surcharge. Compare those exact costs and reliable paid hours before deciding whether a W-2 or independent arrangement leaves the better annual margin.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $93,329 (cost position 18). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,798 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,259 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Indiana’s Department of Insurance administers provider qualification and surcharges for the Patient’s Compensation Fund. Its guidance says only qualified providers receive the Act’s protections. Verify the physician’s qualification and who pays both policy and fund charges; employment alone does not answer those questions.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.493 for Indiana, using published malpractice RVUs across 92 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Indiana retirement-tax details
IowaRead state analysis

Iowa

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $227,300Monthly gross rent $981HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,342

Iowa’s spending basket is among the least expensive, which matters directly for a contractor with reliable profit. Its homeowner tax observation is less favorable than Indiana’s, so a buyer should not stop at rent or purchase price. Price the home near the intended work and compare travel days if the practice relies on assignments outside the state.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $87,762 (cost position 3). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,937 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,342 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.342 for Iowa, using published malpractice RVUs across 99 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Iowa retirement-tax details
KansasRead state analysis

Kansas

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $238,700Monthly gross rent $1,079HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,733

Kansas can offer a modest household cost base, but a physician’s business budget needs the Health Care Stabilization Fund component. The 2026 surcharge depends on classification and must be paired with the underlying policy. A Kansas City-area practice also deserves a precise work-location record rather than a metro label standing in for the state where services are performed.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $90,068 (cost position 10). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,983 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,733 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Kansas publishes a separate Health Care Stabilization Fund surcharge table for calendar 2026. Use the physician’s classification and the correct coverage period, and compare the surcharge plus the underlying policy. The site also posts a future 2027 schedule, which should not be used for a 2026 budget.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 25%; sample 12.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.474 for Kansas, using published malpractice RVUs across 105 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Kansas retirement-tax details
KentuckyRead state analysis

Kentucky

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $226,000Monthly gross rent $998HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,525

Kentucky’s low spending basket, rent and homeowner taxes support a contractor’s household budget at a fixed profit. The selected malpractice-change observations make renewal pricing worth investigating separately. A strong cost score should lead to a quote and a paid-shift plan, not an assumption that all practice overhead shares the same low-cost profile.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $90,159 (cost position 12). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,611 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,525 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 20%; sample 15.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.929 for Kentucky, using published malpractice RVUs across 119 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Kentucky retirement-tax details
LouisianaRead state analysis

Louisiana

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $223,200Monthly gross rent $1,064HO-3 premium, 2023 $3,027

Louisiana’s low everyday prices help a contractor at fixed profit, but the historical home-insurance observation is a meaningful counterweight. The physician budget also needs the patient-fund component where participation applies. Price household coverage and professional coverage separately; a low property-tax bill cannot tell you whether either insurance line is manageable.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $88,207 (cost position 5). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,187 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $3,027 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Louisiana’s Patient’s Compensation Fund provides an excess-coverage layer for enrolled private providers and collects surcharges. A carrier quote without the fund component is an incomplete cost comparison where participation is part of the arrangement. Confirm enrollment, specialty class and who bears each payment.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.972 for Louisiana, using published malpractice RVUs across 64 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Louisiana retirement-tax details
MaineRead state analysis

Maine

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $341,900Monthly gross rent $1,210HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,150

Maine offers a lower price basket and median rent than the other New England states with high purchase benchmarks. Its historical homeowners premium is also modest. A contractor should ask whether assignments and travel support the assumed annual profit; the employee wage is not evidence of a quoted 1099 rate or the number of paid shifts available.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $97,050 (cost position 26). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,103 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,150 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.608 for Maine, using published malpractice RVUs across 16 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: Payment arithmetic is supported by enacted law; implementation forms and filing procedures still need confirmation before an actual election.

Read the Maine retirement-tax details
MarylandRead state analysis

Maryland

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $436,300Monthly gross rent $1,721HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,578

Maryland’s contractor home-base costs are higher than Pennsylvania’s across the price basket, median rent and homeowner tax observations. That makes the housing decision meaningful when profit is held constant. A physician working around state boundaries should also document each service location and residence before comparing tax estimates; a regional client list does not create a single tax jurisdiction.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $104,959 (cost position 44). ACS median homeowner tax is $4,144 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,578 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.062 for Maryland, using published malpractice RVUs across 24 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: 2027 base computation requires its own future-year guidance.

Read the Maryland retirement-tax details
MassachusettsRead state analysis

Massachusetts

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $607,400Monthly gross rent $1,848HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,134

Massachusetts’s homeowner tax and insurance observations add to an already expensive regional basket. A contracting physician should compare the full-year home-base budget with the duration and reliability of assignments. A temporary furnished stay, a rented permanent home and an owner-occupied purchase are different arrangements, so the statewide owner statistics should not be copied into all three.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $105,757 (cost position 45). ACS median homeowner tax is $6,080 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,134 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.853 for Massachusetts, using published malpractice RVUs across 14 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Massachusetts retirement-tax details
MichiganRead state analysis

Michigan

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $254,200Monthly gross rent $1,168HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,110

Michigan’s historical home-insurance observation is modest and its price basket is below national average, although it is not as low as Ohio’s or Indiana’s. For a contractor with fixed profit, those differences are worth evaluating alongside actual housing. If work involves several locations, use paid hours and travel expenses to determine whether the cheaper home base preserves the assumed margin.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $96,217 (cost position 24). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,988 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,110 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.415 for Michigan, using published malpractice RVUs across 83 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Michigan retirement-tax details
MinnesotaRead state analysis

Minnesota

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $344,600Monthly gross rent $1,291HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,988

Minnesota’s fixed-profit household screen faces higher homeowner taxes and insurance than several low-cost alternatives, even though the general price index remains below national average. A contractor choosing it for family or amenities should price those recurring expenses explicitly. The employee wage can suggest a labor-market question, but cannot establish contract availability or business revenue.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $98,621 (cost position 30). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,501 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,988 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.296 for Minnesota, using published malpractice RVUs across 86 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9995%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Minnesota retirement-tax details
MississippiRead state analysis

Mississippi

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $186,500Monthly gross rent $990HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,029

Mississippi is close to Arkansas on the regional price index, making it an attractive fixed-profit household comparison. Homeowners insurance is less of an advantage than the cheap purchase benchmark suggests. A contractor should establish actual paid work and household coverage before assuming the low-cost base leaves the same annual profit available in every assignment arrangement.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $86,953 (cost position 2). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,221 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,029 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.719 for Mississippi, using published malpractice RVUs across 81 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Mississippi retirement-tax details
MissouriRead state analysis

Missouri

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $254,400Monthly gross rent $1,067HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,589

Missouri’s spending basket, rent and homeowner taxes are modest relative to many states, which can help a contractor holding net profit constant. A practice serving both sides of a state boundary still needs separate location records and tax analysis. The household cost advantage does not remove unpaid commuting, travel or the cost of administering multistate assignments.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $90,817 (cost position 13). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,021 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,589 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.999 for Missouri, using published malpractice RVUs across 115 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Missouri retirement-tax details
MontanaRead state analysis

Montana

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $425,400Monthly gross rent $1,177HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,768

Montana’s price basket and statewide rent are lower than Colorado’s, making it a useful home-base alternative for a contractor with equally reliable earnings. The home purchase benchmark is still substantial. Compare temporary assignment housing with owning a permanent base, and determine whether travel and unpaid gaps consume the savings implied by the household cost screen.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $94,645 (cost position 22). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,939 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,768 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.031 for Montana, using published malpractice RVUs across 51 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9896%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: Entity eligibility can require judgment where an S corporation has instruments that may be treated as a second class of stock.

Read the Montana retirement-tax details
NebraskaRead state analysis

Nebraska

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $263,100Monthly gross rent $1,102HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,142

Nebraska’s spending basket is inexpensive, but its homeowner tax and historical insurance observations are higher than several peers with similar general prices. Its regulator’s year-specific FAQ sets the fund surcharge at 5% for policies issued or renewed in 2026. That percentage is an additional coverage expense, not an annual malpractice premium; obtain the qualifying policy and fund charge together.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $90,103 (cost position 11). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,739 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,142 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Nebraska’s Excess Liability Fund requires provider qualification and a separate surcharge. The Department of Insurance’s year-specific FAQ specifies 5% for policies issued or renewed in 2026, versus 35% in 2025. The base is the full qualifying underlying premium before deductible credit. Obtain the policy and fund charge as separate lines; the percentage does not establish a statewide annual malpractice premium.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.457 for Nebraska, using published malpractice RVUs across 81 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9989%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Nebraska retirement-tax details
NevadaRead state analysis

Nevada

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $455,500Monthly gross rent $1,709HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,013

Nevada has a low historical homeowners premium, but the household basket is near national average and median rent is high relative to Wyoming or New Mexico. A contractor seeking a permanent base should compare actual housing before translating a tax headline into spendable margin. Reliable paid hours and assignment travel remain separate from the home’s state.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $99,979 (cost position 34). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,143 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,013 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.833 for Nevada, using published malpractice RVUs across 15 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Nevada retirement-tax details
New HampshireRead state analysis

New Hampshire

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $458,800Monthly gross rent $1,558HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,300

New Hampshire’s historical homeowners insurance is modest, while the median homeowner tax is large. Those two lines should stay separate in a contractor’s budget. A physician based there and accepting assignments elsewhere still needs to review work-state sourcing and paid travel; the home-base choice does not make out-of-state services disappear from the tax analysis.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $104,165 (cost position 43). ACS median homeowner tax is $6,707 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,300 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.863 for New Hampshire, using published malpractice RVUs across 10 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the New Hampshire retirement-tax details
New JerseyRead state analysis

New Jersey

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $496,000Monthly gross rent $1,800HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,551

New Jersey has the largest median homeowner tax observation in this dataset, a meaningful fixed-profit household consideration even before business taxes. Median rent is also high. A contractor comparing it with Pennsylvania or Delaware should separate the cost of residence from the sourcing of each assignment, especially when the practice serves locations on more than one side of a border.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $108,805 (cost position 48). ACS median homeowner tax is $9,358 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,551 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.128 for New Jersey, using published malpractice RVUs across 21 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the New Jersey retirement-tax details
New MexicoRead state analysis

New Mexico

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $279,900Monthly gross rent $1,117HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,490

New Mexico’s lower price basket and rent make a useful comparison with Arizona for a contractor who can maintain the same net practice profit. The question is whether paid assignments, coverage and travel preserve that assumption. No current statewide malpractice premium has been verified here, and proposed or changing rules should not be turned into an assumed insurance saving.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $92,212 (cost position 15). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,776 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,490 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.245 for New Mexico, using published malpractice RVUs across 32 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: No claim of universal refundability; owner credit use must be reconciled.

Read the New Mexico retirement-tax details
New YorkRead state analysis

New York

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $449,800Monthly gross rent $1,634HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,801

New York’s contractor household screen is expensive relative to Pennsylvania on prices, homeowner taxes and historical insurance. Those statewide statistics do not establish the costs of a particular city or a temporary assignment. Track the actual work locations and who pays housing and travel before comparing net margin; the malpractice-change sample supplies a renewal question rather than an annual premium.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $107,921 (cost position 47). ACS median homeowner tax is $6,542 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,801 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 4.3%; sample 69.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.485 for New York, using published malpractice RVUs across 62 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the New York retirement-tax details
North CarolinaRead state analysis

North Carolina

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $333,000Monthly gross rent $1,338HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,852

North Carolina’s price basket and household carrying-cost observations sit between several cheaper inland alternatives and more expensive coastal-state comparisons. For a contractor, the choice should follow reliable net profit and the actual home near work or travel routes. A state mean does not establish that Raleigh, Charlotte and other communities share the same assignment housing costs.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $94,326 (cost position 21). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,044 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,852 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.621 for North Carolina, using published malpractice RVUs across 100 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the North Carolina retirement-tax details
North DakotaRead state analysis

North Dakota

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $266,100Monthly gross rent $980HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,414

North Dakota’s low spending basket and rent are relevant to a contractor’s home base at fixed profit. Its BLS Family Medicine wage should not be copied into a 1099 revenue projection; the series measures employees. Build the year from committed paid hours and actual travel before deciding whether the household cost advantage survives the full assignment schedule.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $88,959 (cost position 8). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,550 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,414 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.299 for North Dakota, using published malpractice RVUs across 49 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9943%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the North Dakota retirement-tax details
OhioRead state analysis

Ohio

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $239,800Monthly gross rent $1,090HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,116

Ohio’s price basket is modest and its historical homeowners insurance observation is low, while homeowner taxes are higher than Indiana’s. A contractor holding profit constant should compare the complete recurring budget rather than just the home purchase. If assignments cross into neighboring states, separate paid clinical time from travel and maintain an accurate location record.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $92,774 (cost position 17). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,937 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,116 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.996 for Ohio, using published malpractice RVUs across 88 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Ohio retirement-tax details
OklahomaRead state analysis

Oklahoma

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $222,100Monthly gross rent $1,044HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,486

Oklahoma’s spending basket is among the least expensive, making it relevant for a contractor with dependable profit. The homeowners insurance observation is considerably higher than Missouri’s and Kansas’s, so a buyer needs a specific quote before choosing a base. Keep professional malpractice coverage separate; neither the home premium nor the state’s general affordability prices the practice.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $87,843 (cost position 4). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,672 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,486 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.750 for Oklahoma, using published malpractice RVUs across 77 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Oklahoma retirement-tax details
OregonRead state analysis

Oregon

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $497,500Monthly gross rent $1,597HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,003

Oregon’s historical homeowners insurance is low in this series, but the spending basket and home-price benchmark remain relatively expensive. A contractor should distinguish a low quoted household coverage cost from total business margin. Determine actual paid hours, professional insurance and work locations before assuming the home-base comparison establishes a lower overall tax or practice cost.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $103,361 (cost position 40). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,895 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,003 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.785 for Oregon, using published malpractice RVUs across 34 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9985%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Oregon retirement-tax details
PennsylvaniaRead state analysis

Pennsylvania

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $277,600Monthly gross rent $1,252HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,217

Pennsylvania’s household costs are lower than New Jersey’s on several imported measures, but the contractor budget needs the 2026 Mcare assessment calculated on its correct schedule base. Do not simply apply the percentage to an insurer’s quoted premium. Match the specialty, territory, actual paid shifts and assessment responsibility before comparing contracts with a neighboring state.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $97,572 (cost position 28). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,214 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,217 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Pennsylvania’s official 2026 Mcare assessment is 29% of the JUA prevailing primary premium for the provider. That is a defined schedule base, not necessarily the commercial premium on a quote. Ask for the underlying policy and Mcare assessment as separate dollar lines before comparing offers or locum contracts.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 52.9%; sample 51.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.073 for Pennsylvania, using published malpractice RVUs across 67 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Pennsylvania retirement-tax details
Rhode IslandRead state analysis

Rhode Island

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $455,700Monthly gross rent $1,418HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,396

Rhode Island’s cost basket is slightly cheaper than Massachusetts’s, but its historical homeowners premium is higher and the owner property-tax observation remains substantial. A contractor should compare exact housing arrangements rather than choose from the general price index alone. The malpractice-change exhibit is another reason to request a current quote, not a numeric substitute for that quote.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $102,280 (cost position 37). ACS median homeowner tax is $4,886 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,396 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 25%; sample 12.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.948 for Rhode Island, using published malpractice RVUs across 5 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Source qualification: PTET: The current source did not support a universal refundability label for every owner class.

Read the Rhode Island retirement-tax details
South CarolinaRead state analysis

South Carolina

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $299,500Monthly gross rent $1,272HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,753

South Carolina’s median homeowner tax is low, while general prices remain below national average. A contractor should still distinguish the actual property and assignment location from the state mean, especially when comparing a permanent base with temporary housing. The selected liability-change observations justify checking renewal terms without claiming a statewide annual malpractice price.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $93,749 (cost position 19). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,337 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,753 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 20%; sample 15.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.893 for South Carolina, using published malpractice RVUs across 46 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the South Carolina retirement-tax details
South DakotaRead state analysis

South Dakota

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $289,600Monthly gross rent $999HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,614

South Dakota’s contractor screen compares a controlled business-income tax base, household spending and malpractice-cost context; its published Family Medicine employee wage remains separate negotiation context. Its low spending basket and median rent can help price a home base. Check the actual paid assignment calendar and coverage, then compare owner property taxes and insurance if buying rather than renting.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $88,586 (cost position 6). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,940 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,614 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.294 for South Dakota, using published malpractice RVUs across 62 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9933%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the South Dakota retirement-tax details
TennesseeRead state analysis

Tennessee

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $332,600Monthly gross rent $1,284HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,649

Tennessee’s low regional basket and modest homeowner carrying-cost observations make it a useful contractor home-base candidate at fixed profit. Median rent is higher than Kentucky’s or Alabama’s, however. Compare the actual neighborhood, travel pattern and paid hours before assuming a statewide affordability advantage translates equally to each assignment arrangement.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $91,870 (cost position 14). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,488 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,649 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.536 for Tennessee, using published malpractice RVUs across 95 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Tennessee retirement-tax details
TexasRead state analysis

Texas

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $313,200Monthly gross rent $1,475HO-3 premium, 2023 $2,864

Texas’s household cost screen is held back by larger homeowner tax and insurance observations despite its below-national price index. A physician contractor should price the actual home and professional policy separately. The statutory noneconomic-damages provision is useful legal context, but it cannot establish a low malpractice quote, eliminate coverage needs or price the business’s state obligations.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $97,057 (cost position 27). ACS median homeowner tax is $4,108 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $2,864 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Texas section 74.301(a) limits noneconomic liability for physicians and other noninstitution providers collectively to $250,000 per claimant. Institutional defendants follow separate provisions. This is not a total damages cap or evidence that every specialty has inexpensive coverage.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.954 for Texas, using published malpractice RVUs across 242 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9996%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Texas retirement-tax details
UtahRead state analysis

Utah

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $545,200Monthly gross rent $1,593HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,107

Utah’s historical homeowners insurance is modest, but its general price basket is not among the cheapest and statewide rent is substantial. A contractor bringing reliable earnings may fare differently from the employee-pay screen because profit is held constant. Build a local housing budget first, then price professional coverage and paid-time assumptions to test the margin.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $98,864 (cost position 31). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,648 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,107 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 25%; sample 12.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.878 for Utah, using published malpractice RVUs across 28 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9999%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Utah retirement-tax details
VermontRead state analysis

Vermont

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $352,800Monthly gross rent $1,319HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,215

Vermont’s fixed-profit home-base comparison benefits from modest historical homeowners insurance, but homeowner taxes remain a significant recurring line. A contractor should compare those owner costs with renting near the work and with actual travel arrangements. The employee wage does not establish a contract rate or enough assignments to sustain the assumed profit.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $97,958 (cost position 29). ACS median homeowner tax is $5,026 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,215 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.501 for Vermont, using published malpractice RVUs across 14 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Vermont retirement-tax details
VirginiaRead state analysis

Virginia

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $403,500Monthly gross rent $1,646HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,537

Virginia’s contractor household basket is more expensive than North Carolina’s, and median rent is higher. A permanent base should therefore be chosen with actual assignments and travel costs in view. A physician with work on both sides of a state line needs specific location records; household residence and practice revenue cannot be collapsed into one statewide cost statistic.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $101,104 (cost position 36). ACS median homeowner tax is $2,872 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,537 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.695 for Virginia, using published malpractice RVUs across 131 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 99.9999%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Virginia retirement-tax details
WashingtonRead state analysis

Washington

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $602,200Monthly gross rent $1,824HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,232

Washington combines an expensive household basket with a separate professional-services B&O question for physician contractors. Keep the household and business calculations apart: low historical home insurance does not offset every cost, and a personal income-tax headline does not settle gross-receipts obligations. Price the assignment and obtain current sourcing and classification analysis before choosing the permanent base.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $107,013 (cost position 46). ACS median homeowner tax is $4,729 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,232 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

Washington WAC 458-20-224 includes physician services in the service-and-other-business-activities B&O classification. A contractor must review gross-receipts obligations and sourcing separately from household income taxes. The score contains no assumed B&O rate or deduction.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.748 for Washington, using published malpractice RVUs across 38 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Washington retirement-tax details
West VirginiaRead state analysis

West Virginia

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $170,800Monthly gross rent $883HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,179

West Virginia’s low spending basket, median rent and homeowner tax can make a lean contractor home base if the assumed profit is reliable. The practice still needs actual assignment and coverage costs. A favorable household score does not establish available shifts or a low malpractice premium; use the cited change observation only to inform renewal due diligence.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $89,497 (cost position 9). ACS median homeowner tax is $881 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,179 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

AMA 2024–2025: ≥10% increases, 8.3%; sample 12.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 1.548 for West Virginia, using published malpractice RVUs across 55 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the West Virginia retirement-tax details
WisconsinRead state analysis

Wisconsin

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $294,700Monthly gross rent $1,142HO-3 premium, 2023 $923

Wisconsin’s historical homeowners insurance is the lowest observation in the dataset, helping the fixed-profit household screen. Homeowner taxes are higher than in Indiana, so the owner budget is not uniformly cheap. A contractor should price the actual home and assignments, and should not import the strong employee wage as expected self-employed earnings.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $94,095 (cost position 20). ACS median homeowner tax is $3,680 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $923 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.289 for Wisconsin, using published malpractice RVUs across 72 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Wisconsin retirement-tax details
WyomingRead state analysis

Wyoming

Back to comparison ↑
Median home $339,500Monthly gross rent $998HO-3 premium, 2023 $1,853

Wyoming’s spending basket and median rent are well below Colorado’s, making it a useful contractor home-base comparison at fixed profit. The actual travel pattern matters: a low-cost residence can require unpaid time and transport to reach assignments. Price those terms and professional coverage before treating the home’s affordability as the practice’s annual cost advantage.

The 2024 BEA index prices a controlled $100,000 basket at $92,691 (cost position 16). ACS median homeowner tax is $1,947 for 2024, and the historical NAIC HO-3 premium is $1,853 for 2023. These household observations do not include practice expenses or malpractice.

The CMS underlying malpractice-cost index aggregates to 0.750 for Wyoming, using published malpractice RVUs across 23 county or planning-region observations. This contributes to the physician score as relative insurance-cost context. The 2026 update uses 2023 mature claims-made premiums and RVUs, with a $1 million/$3 million coverage target; it is not a 2026 premium quote or an assessment of courtroom rules. Observed RVU coverage is 100.0000%. County premiums reflect state-specific specialty mix, and RVU coverage does not measure insurer-market coverage. CMS excludes risk-retention-group filings and imputes some source values, so your specialty, carrier and coverage arrangement still require an actual quote.

Read the Wyoming retirement-tax details
Taxstra methodologyScoring factors, weights, research profiles and limitations.

How Taxstra grades each state out of 10

We score every state using the same rules. Costs and financial factors make up 80% of the overall score, and WalletHub’s Quality of Life category makes up 20%. Each category tile shows how much it counts. Tiles marked “Not in overall score” offer extra context without changing the ranking.

What counts toward the score

  • State tax on $500K of taxable business income: 30% of the financial share
  • Everyday living costs: 40% of the financial share
  • Malpractice insurance costs: 30% of the financial share

What does a score out of 10 mean?

For financial categories, 10 is the strongest result in the comparison and 1 is the weakest. Lower costs generally score better; higher pay scores better. A 7.9 is a comparison tool, not a promise about your finances.

Why can scores and ranks look different?

Cards show one decimal place, while rankings use two. Two states can both display 7.9 and still have slightly different ranks. States with the same ranking value share a rank.

Which WalletHub ranking do we use?

We use WalletHub’s Quality of Life category, not its overall ranking. For example, Illinois is fifth for Quality of Life and eighteenth overall in the cited study. Those are two different measures.

What if information is missing?

We leave it missing instead of guessing. If a required factor is unavailable, we label the score provisional and do not give it an overall rank.

Technical formulas and source definitions

Uses a separately supplied $500K state-taxable ordinary-business base, regional spending and CMS relative malpractice costs. Does not derive a return from $500K profit or assume a contractor pay premium. Entity charges, retirement contributions, federal payroll and assignment-state sourcing remain separate.

Financial categories: actual measurement spread
The most favorable observed value receives 10 and the least favorable receives 1. Intermediate grades are scaled linearly between them: 1 + 9 × the favorable share of the observed range. Lower costs score higher; higher pay scores higher. If every observation is identical, each receives 5.5. These relative grades do not have a universal pass/fail cutoff. Extreme observations can widen the range and compress other grades. We do not narrow a genuine gap just to produce a tighter leaderboard; a change to a source population must have a documented measurement reason. The STR grade is a regional spending-cost screen. Hotel employment is excluded from its score because hotel jobs do not measure residential STR demand; actual occupancy and booking revenue require local property research.
Malpractice and rental taxes: defined samples
The physician index weights CMS county malpractice-cost observations by their malpractice RVUs within each state. It uses the underlying 2026 update, based on 2023 premiums and RVUs, before Medicare payment adjustments. State-specific specialty mix, missing insurer types and CMS imputation limit its use as a quote comparison. Apartment-tax comparisons hold building and fixture values constant and average the study’s named urban and rural municipalities equally. Including both reduces dependence on one city; it still does not represent all localities. They are neither statewide tax rates nor single-family STR bills.
Quality of life: the source category, not the overall WalletHub rank
We use the quality-of-life category of WalletHub’s 2026 state study, published August 10, 2026. Taxstra converts its rank to a grade using 1 + 9 × (50 − rank) / 49. The publisher’s category includes amenities, mobility, leisure, weather and environmental conditions. WalletHub’s overall ranking also includes affordability, economy, education and health, and safety. We use its narrower quality-of-life category as an amenities and daily-life input; our financial factors already measure costs separately. For example, Illinois is #5 in that category and #18 overall in WalletHub. Taxstra’s own guide ranking is a third, separately calculated result. Differences in these rank-based grades are not measured differences in happiness.
Overall grade and rank
Multiply each unrounded component grade by its published weight, add the results, then display one decimal place. Round the composite to two decimals for ranking and retain genuine ties at that precision. Cards display one decimal for readability; two cards displaying 7.9 can therefore have different positions. The table tooltip and downloadable dataset include the ranking value. For example, financial 6.0 and quality of life 9.0 produce 6.6 at 80% financial / 20% quality-of-life weights. Direct tax and deduction comparisons rank their displayed dollar outcomes and show a separate normalized category grade.
Incomplete evidence
Unavailable category data receives no grade. When a weighted component is missing, the remaining components are reweighted and the card labels the result provisional, shows evidence coverage and excludes it from the overall rank. The presence of a numeric provisional grade is not evidence that the missing category was measured.
What a grade does not claim
These are screening grades, not completed all-factor tax or legal rankings. The named tax benchmarks and CMS malpractice-cost index are included only where the displayed weights say so. Full-return taxes, individual insurance quotes and legal-policy judgments remain separate. A high amenities grade does not mean that everyone prefers the state. Family ties, local neighborhoods, climate preferences and a particular job can outweigh statewide observations.

For investment guides, livability describes market context; it does not forecast rent growth or returns and does not assume that the investor lives in the property’s state. In guides about tax bills, the tax calculations stay separate from lifestyle grades.

Research examples and calculation assumptions

Taxstra's research profiles

A useful comparison holds the household and property constant. These are the exact starting profiles for the tax research; a scenario is not a completed tax estimate unless its result is explicitly shown.

Physician employment
$500,000 in wages, one earner, no dependents, no elective retirement contributions. Married filing jointly and single results are separate. The score’s separate tax sensitivity uses $500,000 of state taxable wage income with state AGI equal to that base; it is not a gross-to-taxable return calculation. Compensation observations use the BLS occupation specified beside the result and exclude self-employment.
Contracting and business ownership
$500,000 of profit before owner compensation. An S-corp example tests a $250,000 owner wage; that is a sensitivity assumption, not a reasonable-compensation opinion. The separate employee-payroll example is five employees at $100,000 each. Employee wages already included in operating expenses are never deducted twice.
Retirement
Both spouses are 67, married filing jointly, receiving $120,000 from traditional retirement accounts, $60,000 in private pensions, $60,000 in Social Security, $30,000 in ordinary investment income and $30,000 in long-term capital gains. Each spouse receives half. Total cash income is $300,000; taxable income depends on the income category and applicable rules. Full-year residents. Qualified traditional distributions; employer-funded defined-benefit pension; 401(k) entirely employee elective deferrals with no employer contributions; IRA entirely self-funded with no exempt pension rollover; Pennsylvania-eligible retirement distributions after retirement. Exclusions are applied to qualifying plan income first where several income categories are eligible. No federal or state tax bill is estimated.
Property acquisition
A debt-free $1 million purchase, with $200,000 allocated to land. The long-term rental example assumes $90,000 of rent and $30,000 of expenses before property tax, insurance and depreciation. The STR example assumes $150,000 of bookings and $75,000 of expenses on the same basis. These are research starting profiles, not market forecasts. The standardized scored apartment example is different: $600,000 land and building plus $30,000 fixtures, with the same values across named municipalities. The STR worked example uses a separately labeled fixed property scenario. It does not change the statewide ranking or represent forecast bookings.
Depreciation
A sensitivity considers an additional $100,000 deduction that the taxpayer can currently use. An addback can defer a state benefit even when federal expensing is available. A current deduction, a future recovery and a permanent tax reduction are different results.
State and local scope
Property location and owner residence are separate inputs. There is no assumed “average” local income tax. A combined state/local result needs a named locality and its resident or nonresident rules. Figures explicitly labeled state-only exclude local tax.

How to reproduce a comparison

  1. Choose the named measure and its source year.
  2. Apply the formula displayed beside the map to the source observation for each state.
  3. Round money to whole dollars, ratios to two decimal places and grades to one decimal place. Rank in the direction stated by the measure: the tax-penalty guide places the largest burden first, while its tax-cost grade still rewards a lower bill. Changing display order does not change a state’s rank.
  4. Give equal ranking values the same competition rank (composites use two decimals; cards show one). After a tie, skip the occupied positions.
  5. Leave suppressed or unavailable observations unranked. Retain the state in the table and describe the gap.

A price-adjusted wage, a homeowner tax bill and a lodging-employment concentration answer different questions. The balanced view explicitly combines the guide’s named financial factors with livability at the displayed weights. Other categories provide context. A favorable legal policy is not treated as a measured dollar saving. Material modeling assumptions require review before a full financial ranking is released.

The financial profiles are a $500,000 W-2 household, a business with $500,000 profit before owner compensation, a five-person $500,000 payroll, and a married age-67 household with $300,000 of mixed retirement and investment income. Investor examples assume the purchase location is separate from the owner’s residence.

These scenarios define the research questions. Unless a completed calculation is explicitly shown, a profile is not an estimated return. Tax sensitivities use separately supplied state-taxable wage or ordinary-business bases, exclude local tax and do not replace full-return calculations. We do not calculate with unverified secondary-source schedules.

Published survey estimates have sampling error. We preserve available Census margins of error and BLS relative errors in the source data. Small apparent differences should not be treated as certainty. A comprehensive state decision still requires the actual locality, household, property, employer and coverage terms.

Sources and measurement datesOriginal datasets, primary authority, verification dates and downloadable research.

Download the published 50-state dataset (CSV) · Dataset definitions and coverage

Economic observations were retrieved September 12, 2026. Measurement years differ because the agencies publish on different schedules. Existing retirement rules retain their August 4, 2026 review date; existing PTET and depreciation research retain August 30, 2026. Unresolved entries remain identified.

The Census property-tax figure is a median dollar bill on owner-occupied homes, not a tax rate on rentals. BLS physician wages exclude self-employment. NAIC premiums describe owner-occupied HO-3 policies. CMS healthcare spending includes several payers and all ages. BLS accommodation employment includes hotels and other lodging; it is not STR revenue.

State-specific primary-authority links appear with each state. A source listed for one tax category does not verify a different category.

Common questions

Is the cheapest state to live in the best state for locums?

Not necessarily. The home-base cost ranking holds net practice profit constant. Assignment availability, work-state sourcing, coverage and travel can reverse the household comparison.

Can I use the BLS physician salary as my expected 1099 income?

No. BLS OEWS excludes self-employed physicians. A locum projection must use actual contracted rates, paid hours and expenses.

Does incorporating in another state remove my home-state obligations?

Formation alone does not determine residency, work-state sourcing, professional licensure or business activity. Review where the physician actually lives and performs services.

Does the guide assume every physician should elect S-corp taxation?

No. The election requires a lawful professional structure and a combined comparison of wages, payroll, state charges, retirement plans and administration. The illustrated owner salary is not a compensation opinion.

What is the difference between a malpractice premium and a fund surcharge?

The premium purchases the underlying insurance policy. Certain state arrangements add a separate payment for fund participation or excess coverage. Obtain both amounts and determine whether the agency, hospital or physician bears each cost.

Why is a malpractice increase percentage not part of the score?

A share of sampled premiums that increased is not an annual dollar cost. A low-premium state can have a large percentage increase, while an expensive policy can stay unchanged. Scoring the increase as affordability would confuse different measurements.

Can a hospital 401(k) and solo 401(k) each get the full employee deferral?

The IRS says the elective deferral limit is by person, not by plan. Employer contributions and other limits require a separate earnings and plan review.

Is this a business-profit tax calculator?

No. It compares a controlled owner-tax benchmark, regional costs, CMS malpractice-cost context and quality of life. The owner-tax base is supplied separately from practice profit. Federal, local, entity and resident-credit reconciliation remain separate.

Does the score calculate tax on my practice profit?

No. The score compares a separately supplied $500,000 state-taxable business-income base; it does not convert gross collections or net profit into taxable income. The interactive operating example reconciles owner wages and employer FICA separately, and shows verified entity components. Review those published inputs to investigate your facts, then reconcile a full return.

How much should lifestyle matter for a traveling physician?

Consider your home base and assignment locations separately. School, family and recurring living costs belong to the home-base decision. Travel time, schedule quality and temporary housing belong to the contract comparison. One statewide score cannot settle both.

Can employee wage data predict my 1099 income?

No. Employee wage observations provide labor-market context. A contractor needs actual rates, paid hours, cancellations and expenses to estimate profit. The guide does not turn employee wages into invented locum compensation.

How should I compare two locum contracts?

Compare expected annual net collections after unpaid time, travel, lodging, licensing and insurance costs. Then compare schedule flexibility and the locations where you will actually work. Keep your household budget separate from practice expenses.

Does the balanced score include every S-corp cost?

No. Its financial component is the named screening measure, not a complete entity calculation. Payroll, professional-entity requirements, administration and multistate obligations still need an individual comparison.

Why can the WalletHub rank differ from the rank on this card?

The card identifies WalletHub’s Quality of Life category rank. The linked study also has a separate Overall Rank column that incorporates affordability, economy, education and health, and safety. Illinois is #5 in Quality of Life but #18 overall in the 2026 WalletHub study. Taxstra’s headline rank combines the named financial factors with that quality-of-life category using our published weights; it is not WalletHub’s overall ranking.

Can readers customize the published ranking?

No. Each guide uses one fixed methodology and the same assumptions for every state. State search, map selection, shared links and embedded cards all use that published ranking. Separate financial examples explain the assumptions without changing the leaderboard.

How does Taxstra include livability in the ranking?

Composite guides combine their named financial factors with WalletHub’s Quality of Life category at fixed, guide-specific weights: 80% financial and 20% quality of life for physician and retirement composites; 90% financial and 10% quality of life for business and property composites. Direct tax, PTET and depreciation comparisons do not include quality of life in their ranking. Everyone sees the same ranking; choosing a state changes the displayed card, not the methodology. The score is a comparison tool, not an estimate of happiness or a completed tax return.

What does the livability measure include?

We use WalletHub’s 2026 quality-of-life category, which considers amenities, mobility, environmental conditions and leisure. Its methodology is linked in the sources. This category does not fully capture family ties, personal climate preferences, a particular school district or an individual neighborhood.

Does a score of 8.0 mean a state is 80% better?

No. The 1–10 grades describe relative results within the comparison. A score of 8.0 is neither a percentage tax saving nor a probability that you will enjoy living there. Review the underlying measures, fixed weights and limitations before making a shortlist.

Why can two states share a rank?

Taxstra ranks composite scores rounded to two decimals while cards display one decimal. Equal ranking values share the same competition rank. Direct dollar comparisons rank whole-dollar outcomes. Missing observations remain unranked when the selected calculation needs them; they are not replaced with zero.

Continue your research

Use the related calculator · View all 14 guides

Make the comparison yours.

Bring your offer, income mix or property numbers. Taxstra can help connect the state rules to a coordinated plan.